To contact Councillor Matlow click here.
You are Invited to our Davisville Village Community Festival!
Join me and your neighbors at June Rowlands Park (220 Davisville Avenue) from 12:00pm-4:00pm on Saturday June 15th. We will have free ice cream and samosas (while supplies last) and will be raffling off over $2,000 in prizes from local businesses! Community groups, city divisions and local organizations will be setting-up booths to inform and educate residents. We look forward to seeing you on June 15th!
My Letter to Residents Regarding Necessary Action to Combat Antisemitism Throughout Our City
Dear residents,The rise of antisemitism over the past few years has our city’s Jewish community feeling scared and vulnerable. Since October 7th, they’ve far too often been a target for anti-Jewish hate because of a war half a world away. Swastikas spray-painted on synagogues, some demonstration signs displaying hateful antisemitic tropes, and vandalism of Jewish businesses echo a history of religious persecution for many in Toronto’s Jewish community that are only a couple generations removed from the Holocaust. The early morning shooting at Bais Chaya Mushka Girls Elementary School in North York over the weekend has further heightened the fear the community is feeling. Real and concrete action is needed to protect the Jewish community from hate and ensure that everyone feels safe in our city. That’s why it’s critically important that my motion to develop a new action plan to protect targeted religious minorities and places of worship was supported at Council. The motion requests the City Manager, the City Solicitor, the Toronto Police Service and other relevant divisions to work together to ensure individuals and groups committing hate crimes are stopped.There was another motion at Council that proposed creating “safety zones” around places of worship and other faith-based sites. As initially written, the motion was far too broad, as it would have restricted protest at museums and other institutions of a “cultural nature”. That could have impeded, for example, the rights of AGO workers to picket during their recent strike. While I could not support the motion as written, I also recognized that it was not enough to simply vote against it without providing a path forward. I did strongly consider moving a pared-down version myself that would specifically create “safety zones” around places of worship. If there was a way that this initiative could protect faith-based institutions, it was worth exploring. Unfortunately, the details revealed that the promise didn’t stand up to scrutiny.First, the motion regarding the suggested “safety zones” was just a request to the province. This motion did not demand any action on behalf of the City or our police. The Premier has shown no indication that he has any intention of moving forward with such a strategy despite the idea having been proposed months ago. It is important that the City and the police address these pressing issues quickly instead of shirking responsibility by simply writing letters to other levels of government.Second, and most importantly, even if this measure was implemented by the province, it wouldn’t address the very real fears of the Jewish community and other targeted religious minorities. Some are absurdly suggesting that these “safety zones” would lead to something like a ring of cops around all places of worship and faith-based schools in our city. This is an obvious impossibility given the thousands of synagogues, mosques, churches, and temples in Toronto. According to the Councillors proposing this idea, the “safety zones” would be modelled on an existing law protecting abortion clinics with “bubble zones”. A closer look at this legislation reveals that protests aren’t banned outside clinics - only speech that specifically discourages patients from entering the building and accessing healthcare. That is not a parallel to our concerns. Extending this legislation to religious facilities would obviously have done nothing to stop the 5am shooting at Bais Chaya Mushka, and the hate speech and actions that we are all concerned about are already restricted and illegal. Further, incidents of hate crimes have more often occurred away from specifically religious settings. Threatening and unsettling graffiti on buildings, targeted vandalism and slurs in our parks and streets are much more common. Jewish parents are also concerned about the increase in antisemitic slurs and bullying occurring in our public schools. While “safety zones” would not address these issues, I will be meeting with parents, Principals and school board officials to discuss how best to support and protect children.Lastly, while the City Solicitor said that the motion itself did not pose any legal concerns as it was just a request to another level of government, she expressed serious doubt over whether implementing “safety zones” that restrict protest at religious institutions would stand up in court. For example, would restricting the rights of Indigenous Peoples to protest at a Catholic church over the abuses suffered at a residential school be allowable? What if a church similar to Westboro Baptist, that routinely preaches hate against LGBTQ+ communities, came to Canada? Would the courts allow an infringement on the right to protest in these cases?In short, the advice I received from the City Solicitor, the Chief of Police and others, in addition to the evidence in front of me, led to the conclusion that the “safety zone” idea sounds good but would be ineffective, probably unconstitutional, and unlikely to ever be implemented.Let’s not waste any more time pursuing metaphorical caution tape when there are real issues to be addressed. I have already moved forward on the Council direction stemming from my motion by arranging a roundtable meeting for next week to bring together senior City Officials, the Chief of Police and Jewish community leaders to ensure that our concerns are addressed. I will be sure to provide updates as this initiative progresses
Comments